Fishing the Nicoya Peninsula

The short answer

The Nicoya Peninsula is where Costa Rica's sportfishing goes small and personal. Between Playa Garza in the north and Cabo Blanco at the southern tip there isn't a single sportfishing marina, so nearly every trip starts with a wade through the shallows to a panga or a center console waiting off the beach, or a short water taxi to a boat on a mooring. In return, the drop-off is close, the boats are rarely crowded, and you often fish with a captain who grew up in the village.

Inshore, roosterfish, snapper, jacks and sierra mackerel bite around the rocky points and islands in every month. Offshore, a half day can reach water where sailfish, yellowfin tuna and dorado feed. The gulf side, from Tambor and Paquera across to Puntarenas, is calmer and more sheltered, with corvina and snook in the inner gulf.

Three things set the rules of the game here. The Cabo Blanco Absolute Reserve, at the very tip, is closed to all fishing on land and sea. The inner Gulf of Nicoya shuts to fishing every year from 1 May to 31 July to protect spawning corvina. And, as everywhere in Costa Rica, every billfish goes back in the water and everyone fishing from a boat needs an INCOPESCA licence (our guide to Costa Rica's fishing rules has the details).

If you only remember one planning tip, make it this: the peninsula is long and its roads are slow, so pick your base by where the boat leaves from, not the other way round.

Loading the map…

Towns and where the boats leave from

The peninsula splits neatly into 2 coasts. The Pacific side, from Nosara down to Malpaís, faces open ocean and swell. The gulf side, from Cabuya and Montezuma round to Tambor, Paquera and across the water to Puntarenas, is sheltered and shallower. Here's how each town works for an angler.

Nosara and Playa Garza

Nosara is a spread-out surf and yoga town, but its fishing happens a few minutes south at Playa Garza, a fishing village on a curved, protected bay. This is the busiest small-boat fishing beach on the peninsula. Most crews meet guests on the sand (several use the parking lot at Pilo's Bar and Restaurant as their check-in point) and run them out by water taxi to boats on moorings in the bay.

The fleet ranges from 26-foot center consoles to restored sportfishers, and the blue water is unusually close. When Coastal Angler covered the Ship of Fools tournament at Garza in 2019, the fleet was fishing about 12 miles out in 2,100 feet of water on day one. That's why Garza crews can offer a real offshore half day.

Sámara and Playa Carrillo

Sámara sits on a wide bay sheltered by a reef, with Isla Chora at its mouth. Boats launch straight off the beach (Gladiator Sportfishing gives its meeting point as the end of Sámara beach on the road to the Hotel Hideaway) and you'll usually wade out to board. A few kilometers south, Puerto Carrillo's bay is home to a handful of larger boats, including at least one diesel sportfisher that has fished there for decades. Our Sámara fishing guide covers the town in more depth.

Malpaís and Santa Teresa

The surf towns on the peninsula's southwest coast don't look like fishing towns, but the little harbor at the south end of Malpaís is a working fishing village, and that's where most local captains keep their boats. Expect pangas and center consoles in the 22 to 30-foot range, and crews who'll happily mix fishing with snorkeling or whale watching. Jason Tours, one of the local outfits, defines its inshore trips as within about 7 miles of the coast and its offshore trips as beyond about 12. For the towns themselves, santa-teresa.com's guide to fishing tours is a good local read.

Cabuya

Cabuya is a quiet village a few kilometers past Montezuma, right on the edge of the Cabo Blanco reserve. SpicyTuna Cabuya puts it about 7 km south of Montezuma. A handful of family captains fish from here in small boats, and several pick guests up on Montezuma beach at first light. Cabuya's boats know the reserve's boundaries well, which matters, because the best-looking water near the cape is off-limits.

Montezuma and Cóbano

Montezuma has no harbor and its beach is rocky and exposed, so it's a base rather than a port. Tour desks in town sell fishing trips with local captains, some leaving from the beach in the early morning and others from Tambor's calmer bay about half an hour north. Cóbano, the inland crossroads town, has a small tackle shop and the area's airstrip. Our Montezuma guide has more on the town.

Tambor and Pochote (Bahía Ballena)

Bahía Ballena is a wide, calm bay with the villages of Tambor and Pochote on its shore. It's the most sheltered launch point on the southern peninsula, and the pier at the Bahía Ballena Yacht Club in Tambor is where Montezuma Crew starts every trip. Pochote Ocean Adventures runs a 26-foot panga from Calle Playa Pochote. From here it's a short hop to Isla Tortuga and the open gulf.

Paquera and Curú

Paquera is the ferry town, and most visitors drive straight through it. Anglers shouldn't. About 1.5 km east of the ferry landing, at Punta Cuchillo, Bahía Rica runs the only dedicated fishing lodge on this stretch of coast. The Curú wildlife refuge, just south, protects a bay and its beaches. Our shorter guide to the southern Nicoya Peninsula covers this gulf-side stretch as a trip.

Puntarenas

Puntarenas is the old port on a long sand spit on the mainland side of the gulf. It's not a resort fishing town, but it has the most commercial fishing activity in the zone, a big cruise pier, the ferry terminals and several tour operators who run inshore gulf trips. Turismo Marítimo del Pacífico, for example, sails from the Guima Frost Marina in Barrio El Cocal, about 400 m east of the cruise dock.

Marinas, docks and beach launches

There are no full-service sportfishing marinas on the peninsula. The nearest are at Los Sueños in Herradura (across the gulf, covered in our Central Pacific guide) and at Flamingo (see the Guanacaste guide). What you'll find instead:

• Beach launches at Playa Garza, Sámara, Carrillo, Malpaís, Cabuya and Montezuma. Small boats are pushed off the sand, or wait at anchor while you wade or take a water taxi out. Wear shorts and water shoes and bring a dry bag for your phone.
• Moorings in the protected bays at Garza and Carrillo, where the larger boats stay in the water.
• Piers and docks on the gulf side: the Bahía Ballena Yacht Club pier at Tambor, the shore at Punta Cuchillo by Paquera, and docks along the Puntarenas estuary.

A beach launch on the Pacific side depends on the surf. On big-swell mornings, captains may move the meeting point to a more sheltered beach, push the start time earlier, or call the trip off, and good ones will tell you the night before. The gulf side rarely has that problem.

Fuel, ice and bait are normally the crew's job, not yours. Ask what's included when you book (bait, ice, drinks, lunch, cleaning your fish), and if you'll want to take fillets home, bring or ask for a cooler.

Best outfitters on the Nicoya Peninsula

We chose these on evidence alone: years on the water, recent dated reviews (2026), named boats and crews, and what they say about releasing fish. Nobody pays to be listed, and the full list of every business we found is further down. We opened each one's website or booking page on 14 November 2026 to make sure it's live.

North: Nosara, Garza, Sámara and Carrillo

• Monkey Head Adventures (Playa Garza). Two boats, the 32-foot Rampage Osprey and a 27-foot Ticorette, run by owner and captain Jordanny Garcia and captain Alex Moreno, both raised in Garza. Moreno's team qualified for the 2026 Offshore World Championship. Inshore and offshore half, three-quarter and full days, with check-in at Pilo's parking lot.
• Costa Catch Nosara (Playa Garza). One 28-foot walkaround, La Bonita, with captain Marco and mates Guillermo and Nelson. It has 65 reviews on FishingBooker, the latest from a trip on 3 November 2026, and the team placed 3rd in the Ship of Fools billfish tournament in 2022.
• Nosara Sea Saw Tours (Playa Garza). Owner and captain Juri Speca lists 17 years of experience and runs the 26-foot center console Sea Saw and a Boston Whaler, FantaSea, plus a catamaran for wildlife trips. Water taxi from the beach to the boat.
• Juan Mora Sportfishing (Playa Garza). Captain Juan Mora and his family crew fish a restored 31-foot Bertram with twin diesels, kept on a mooring off Garza beach. Recent trips logged through August 2026.
• Gladiator Sportfishing (Sámara). Owner and captain Simone Passarelli runs the 28-foot center console Sol de Oro and a 24-foot panga from the end of Sámara beach. The listing states that roosterfish, sailfish, marlin and jacks are always released.
• Kingfisher Sportfishing (Puerto Carrillo). Captain Rick Ruhlow and mate Orlando run a 31-foot diesel sportfisher out of Carrillo, where the listing says Rick has fished for about 35 years. Full days only, with reviewed trips from late 2025 and January 2026.

South: Malpaís, Cabuya, Tambor and Paquera

• Costa Rican Tropical Tours (Malpaís). A local crew led by captain Mincho, with about 178 TripAdvisor reviews and the latest from July 2026. Inshore roosterfish and offshore tuna, sailfish and marlin from the Malpaís fishing village, plus snorkel and Tortuga trips. It has no website, so book through the listing.
• SpicyTuna Cabuya (Cabuya). Two boats, the 20-foot Spicy Tuna and the 26-foot Twin Souls, on 4, 6 and 8-hour trips. Its site says marlin and sailfish are released and the crew cleans and fillets the fish you keep.
• Montezuma Crew (Tambor). One 32-foot center console with a captain and mate, sailing from the Bahía Ballena pier for inshore mornings, full offshore days 20 to 25 miles out, and Tortuga dives. Billfish are released.
• Bahía Rica Fishing and Kayak Lodge (Paquera). A small Norwegian-owned lodge with its own boats, including the 25-foot super panga Mono Congo, captain Thomas and a local crew. The FishingBooker listing claims 20 years of experience and says most fish are released.
• Turismo Marítimo del Pacífico (Puntarenas). Founded in 2010 by captain Marco Guzmán, it runs 5-hour inshore trips in the Gulf of Nicoya on 2 center consoles from the Guima Frost Marina, with cruise-port pickups.

Fishing lodges and good bases to stay

Fishing lodges, in the sense of a place where the boats leave from the dock and everyone at dinner fished that day, are rare here. Two come close:

• Bahía Rica, at Punta Cuchillo near Paquera, sells fishing-and-stay packages and also runs kayak and Isla Tortuga trips, so it suits a mixed group.
• Samara Deep Sea Fishing and Lodge is a family business in Sámara run by captain Helber Ruiz, with rooms as well as inshore and offshore trips. It has about 144 TripAdvisor reviews, the latest from July 2026.

Montezuma Crew also rents houses in Montezuma, which makes it easy to book a bed and a boat together. Our lodges guide covers fishermen-run places across the country.

For everyone else, the right base is simply the town your boat leaves from:

• For Garza boats: stay in Nosara (Guiones or Pelada) or in Garza itself.
• For Sámara and Carrillo: Sámara has the most choice, Carrillo's hillside hotels are closer to the boats.
• For Malpaís boats: Santa Teresa and Malpaís have the biggest choice of hotels and rentals on the southern peninsula. santa-teresa.com covers them.
• For Cabuya, Montezuma and Tambor boats: Montezuma for village life, Tambor for quiet, Cabuya to be closest to the reserve.
• For Paquera and Puntarenas: Bahía Rica, or a night in Puntarenas if you're catching an early ferry.

What's biting, month by month

The peninsula sits between 2 seasons. Its northern Pacific coast, from Nosara to Carrillo, tends to follow Guanacaste, where the best sailfish months run about May to August. The southern tip and the gulf mouth share more with the Central Pacific, where sailfish peak from about December to April. In practice, captains at both ends catch sailfish in most months, and inshore fishing doesn't really have an off season. Our month-by-month seasons guide has the national picture.

This follows our national season chart: roosterfish strongest January to April, dorado July to December, yellowfin and wahoo May to August, blue marlin May to September and again November and December. Treat it as a guide. Water temperature, bait and weather move the fish around from one year to the next, and the best information is always what the local crews caught last week.

Yellowfin deserve a special mention. On the southern peninsula, from Malpaís round to Cabuya and Montezuma, they're the fish many small boats build their offshore day around, often found under feeding birds and alongside dolphin pods. Several crews serve tuna fresh on board as sashimi or carpaccio.

Inshore, offshore and the named fishing grounds

Inshore: rocks, islands and river mouths

Almost all of the peninsula's coast is broken rock, small islands and river mouths, which is ideal roosterfish and snapper water. The classic inshore trip is a 4 or 5-hour morning: catch live bait on the way out, then slow-troll it along the rocks or cast poppers into the white water. Expect roosterfish, cubera, red and yellowtail snapper, jack crevalle, sierra mackerel, grouper and the odd amberjack.

Inshore ground worth knowing by name:

• Isla Chora, the islet at the mouth of Sámara's bay. It's a wildlife refuge, and FECOP and MarViva's guide lists it as allowing sport fishing only in set zones.
• The Manzanillo rocky banks off the Pacific side near Santa Teresa, the only place in the Cabo Blanco marine management area where spearfishing is allowed.
• Isla Tortuga and the Negritos and Cedros islands in the gulf mouth. They're inside the Paquera-Tambor responsible fishing area, where the Tortuga zone is set aside for recreation and tourism. Treat Tortuga as a swim and snorkel stop and fish the open water around it, as your captain directs.
• The edge of the Cabo Blanco reserve. The reserve's water is closed, so Cabuya and Malpaís captains fish the open water outside its line.

Offshore: the blue water is close

The continental shelf runs close to the peninsula's Pacific side, so even a half day can reach deep water. Crews troll lures or rigged baits looking for current lines, floating logs, weed and birds. Sailfish, blue, black and striped marlin, yellowfin, dorado and wahoo are the targets. From Garza the fleet often fishes 12 miles out or more. From Tambor, Montezuma Crew's full days run 20 to 25 miles offshore.

Watch the birds. Boobies and terns diving on bait are the best fish-finder on this coast, and captains will run a long way to reach a working flock, especially for tuna.

The Gulf of Nicoya: corvina, snook and calm water

The Gulf of Nicoya is a big, shallow, muddy-bottomed estuary fed by the Tempisque and other rivers, edged with mangroves and dotted with islands (Chira, Venado, San Lucas, Caballo and more). It's a working fishery for hundreds of small boats and a very different kind of fishing from the open Pacific. Inshore trips out of Puntarenas look for corvina, snook, snapper, jacks, mackerel and, in the outer gulf, roosterfish and the occasional dorado. Coco's Tours, for example, lists mackerel, dorado, roosterfish, jacks, snook and corvina on its gulf trips.

The gulf is also heavily regulated, with a patchwork of responsible fishing areas, a national park and a yearly closed season, so it's one place where you really want a local operator who knows the lines. The next section has the details.

Protected areas and the rules here

The national rules apply everywhere: an INCOPESCA licence for everyone fishing from a boat (you can apply online with the English application form), billfish released at the boat, and no selling sport catches. FECOP and MarViva's best-practice guide sums up the main ones for anglers:

• Sailfish and marlin are released. Use natural bait on circle hooks, keep the fish in the water and never gaff it or lift it aboard for a photo.
• Roosterfish are a sport-interest species too, and can't be sold.
• Sport anglers may land a maximum of 5 fish a trip, for eating or mounting.

On top of those, this zone has more protected water than any other on the Pacific. Here's what applies where, based on MarViva's 2024 handbook to the gulf's fishing rules, FECOP and MarViva's guide, and INCOPESCA's own documents.

A few practical notes:

• The gulf closure is the big one. INCOPESCA closed the inner gulf from 1 May to 31 July in both 2025 and 2026 to protect 3 species of corvina while they spawn, and MarViva says the closure covers sport fishing. In 2025 the agreement allowed a few narrow exceptions, including small tourist boats fishing seaward of the Puntarenas lighthouse. The details change from year to year, so if you're fishing out of Puntarenas between May and July, ask the operator exactly where they can go.
• Bahía Ballena is a departure point, not a fishing spot. Boats from Tambor and Pochote run out of the bay to fish.
• Ostional still has no management plan. A 2025 letter from SINAC confirms it, so the "set zones" aren't easy to look up. Local captains know them.
• Commercial fishing is banned in river mouths (a 1 km half-circle off the mouth under the fishing law), which helps the snook and snapper there.

For the full national picture, including licence options and what you can keep, see our rules guide and our page on conservation and catch and release.

Bait, tackle and ice nearby

Charter crews supply rods, reels, lures and bait, so most visitors never need a tackle shop. If you're bringing your own spinning gear for shore fishing, or want a spare popper, these are the shops our research found open in 2026:

• Pablo's Fishing Tackle, Nosara: fresh and saltwater gear and local advice. Newest Google review November 2026.
• Rusty Hook Tackle Shop, Santa Teresa, about 20 m north of the Mega Super: sells and rents fishing, kayak and snorkel gear and runs trips, including kayak fishing.
• PenínsulaCR Lures and Tackle, Cóbano: lures and tackle.
• Ciclo Cabécar, Avenida 1, Puntarenas: a bike shop that also sells fishing gear.
• Carnadas del Golfo, Punta Morales (on the mainland shore of the gulf, north of Puntarenas): a bait supplier.

Bring anything specialised from home: braid and leader in the sizes you like, your favourite poppers, and circle hooks if you plan to fish live bait for billfish. There's no dedicated fly shop anywhere in Costa Rica. Your captain will have the boat's ice sorted, and town supermarkets are the place to look if you need ice for your own cooler. Our bait and tackle guide lists shops across the country.

Getting there

The peninsula is close to San José on a map and far away in hours, because the Gulf of Nicoya is in the way. You have 3 options: fly, drive around the gulf, or drive to Puntarenas and take the ferry.

By air

SANSA flies from San José to Nosara (NOB) and to Cóbano (ACO), which it lists as Santa Teresa-Malpaís. Green Airways flies to the same 2 airstrips. Tambor's airstrip, long the gateway to the southern peninsula, no longer appears on either airline's route list: Green Airways says flights booked to Tambor now land at the new Cóbano airport instead. There are no scheduled flights to Sámara or Carrillo, so for those, fly to Nosara or drive from Liberia.

The nearest international airports are Liberia (LIR) for the north of the peninsula and San José (SJO) for the south.

By road

These are averages from Enter Costa Rica and Costa Rica Vibes. The last stretch into Nosara and the southern towns is slow, and the coast road between Sámara and Santa Teresa crosses rivers that can be impassable in the rainy season, so don't plan to drive the length of the peninsula on a whim. A 4x4 helps everywhere south of Cóbano.

By ferry

Naviera Tambor runs the car ferry from Puntarenas to Paquera, with 8 sailings a day each way (the timetable from 20 April 2026 lists 4:00, 6:30 and 9:00 AM, noon, and 3:00, 6:00, 8:00 and 10:00 PM). Part of each boat is sold online and the rest at the terminal. The crossing takes about an hour and a quarter. Bahía Rica is only 1.5 km from the Paquera landing, and santa-teresa.com puts the drive from Paquera to the Santa Teresa coast at about an hour and a quarter. Coonatramar runs a second ferry from Puntarenas to Playa Naranjo, farther up the gulf. santa-teresa.com's ferry guide has tips on timing and tickets. Our trip planning guide covers the rest.

Where to eat your catch

We couldn't confirm, with 2025 or 2026 evidence, any restaurant on the peninsula that advertises cooking guests' own fish, so we're not naming one. Here's how it works locally instead.

Most crews will clean and fillet the fish you keep (SpicyTuna Cabuya says so on its site), and some serve fresh tuna on the boat as sashimi or carpaccio. Tours and More, near Cóbano, makes it part of its trips. Back on land, the usual approach is to ask your captain which beach restaurant or soda in his village will cook it. It's a common favour along this coast, and the cook will usually grill it, fry it whole or turn it into ceviche, with rice, salad and patacones on the side. Ask the price before they start, and a tip for the cook is customary.

If you're staying somewhere with a kitchen, ask for the fillets bagged and iced. Remember that sport catches can't be sold, and billfish and roosterfish never come home.

Weather and sea conditions

The peninsula follows the North Pacific pattern described by the national weather service (IMN):

• Dry season, December to March. Almost no rain (the IMN puts it at about 4% of the year's total), sunny days and clear water. Northeast trade winds blow, which can make afternoons choppy on the open coast in the north, so morning trips are the norm.
• April and November are changeover months.
• First rains, May to August, often with a drier spell (the veranillo) in July or August. Mornings are usually calm and the fishing is good.
• Wettest months, September and October. Rivers swell and color the inshore water, and the open Pacific side gets its biggest surf. The gulf side and the moored boats keep fishing more often than the beach launches.

The peninsula gets about 1,900 mm of rain a year by the IMN's count, more in the south. For a beach-launch coast, the swell matters more than the rain: a captain who cancels on a big-surf morning is doing you a favour. Our weather page has more on Costa Rica's seasons.

Tournaments in the zone

The zone's best-known event is the Ship of Fools billfish tournament at Playa Garza. Coastal Angler reported in 2019 that it was in its 15th straight year, and described it as one of the last pure release tournaments in the country: each scoring fish must be touched on the bill by hand and photographed, with no quick leader releases. That year captain Alex Moreno won for the FishingNosara team with 1,700 points, and the fleet released 11 sailfish, a black marlin and a blue marlin. Costa Catch Nosara says it placed 3rd in 2022. We couldn't find a published date or results for 2025 or 2026, so ask the Garza crews.

On the gulf, INCOPESCA allowed a small tourist and sport tournament off the Puntarenas lighthouse on 12 July 2025, during the closed season.

The country's big billfish events are at Los Sueños and Quepos, across the gulf. Our tournaments guide lists them all.

Every fishing business on the Nicoya Peninsula

This is every charter, captain and fishing tour business we found operating in the zone in 2025 or 2026. It doesn't mean we've fished with all of them. Agencies that resell other captains' trips are marked.